Roofing in Pittsburgh: Slate, Ice Dams, and Steep Hillside Roofs

Some of the roofs here are a century old and worth repairing. Others are at the end of a second layer of shingles.

Pittsburgh's roofing conversation has a branch most metros do not: slate. The city's older neighborhoods carry a substantial number of slate roofs, some of them original and still serviceable with proper repair, and the first question on those houses is not which shingle to buy but whether the slate can be maintained. On the rest of the stock — 73.1% of housing predates 1980 — the familiar issues apply: ice dams at the eave, attics built before ventilation was a design requirement, and roofs already carrying a second layer. The hills add a practical complication: access and staging on a steep lot.

Slate is worth a specializt's opinion

A slate roof that is leaking in one place is often a flashing or fastener problem rather than a failed roof, and repairing it costs far less than replacement. Replacing it with asphalt is a permanent downgrade of both lifespan and appearance. Ask whether the person quoting has actually worked on slate, what the repair would involve, and whether the flashings at chimneys, valleys and wall junctions are the source. A general roofer who proposes replacement without discussing repair has told you what they know.

Ice dams and the membrane under the covering

With 44.1 inches of snow a year and a January mean of 28.8°F, snow sits and melts repeatedly, and water refreezes at the cold eave. The backstop for what gets under the covering there is a waterproof membrane under the shingles. Ask how far up the slope it runs, whether valleys and penetrations are covered too, and how the detail is handled where the roof meets a wall or a dormer. On a house with a history of ice dams, that answer matters more than the shingle brand.

Ventilation and old attic construction

The attics under these roofs were built before modern ventilation practice, and many have insulation blown over the soffit vents or a bath fan discharging into the space. Both make ice dams more likely and shorten the life of the covering. Ask what the ventilation calculation is, whether baffles will protect the intake, and whether an attic fan will be corrected while the roof is open. That is the cheapest moment it will ever be fixed.

How many layers are already there

A house built in 1950 may carry two layers of shingles. A layover is cheaper up front and hides the deck, adds weight, and complicates the next replacement. If a bid assumes one, ask what happens if the deck is soft, whether repairs are priced per sheet, and whether a tear-off alternative is quoted. On a steep roof over a hillside lot, disposal and staging costs are part of the comparison and are easy to leave out.

Access, staging and steep lots

A roof on a hillside property may be three storeys above the street and one above the back garden, which changes how materials are delivered and how safely the work can be done. Ask how the contractor will stage the job, whether a lift or scaffolding is included, and how debris will be removed without crossing a neighbor's property. Those practicalities show up in the price and, more importantly, in whether the job is done safely.

Questions to ask before signing

- If the roof is slate, has the person quoting worked on slate, and is repair an option? - How far up the slope does the eave membrane run, and does it cover valleys? - Is this a tear-off or a layover, and how many layers exist now? - What ventilation exists, and what will be added or cleared? - How will the job be staged on this lot, and is scaffolding or a lift included? - What is the workmanship warranty, and does it transfer with the house?

Where this page stops

This page does not inspect roofs and publishes no prices. Deck condition, slate condition and structural capacity require on-site assessment, and insurance questions belong to the carrier and the policy.

Pittsburgh metro context

ACS 2024 5-year estimates put the metro at about 2.44 million residents in 1,061,705 households and 1,174,149 housing units, with 70.7% owner-occupied and 68.0% single-family detached. About 73.1% of units were built before 1980, the highest share on this site, which is why slate and original attic construction are live topics here. NOAA's station records January at 28.8°F and 44.1 inches of snow a year.

Pittsburgh snow, temperature and housing age

NOAA NCEI 1991–2020 normals for Pittsburgh International Airport (USW00094823); U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2024 5-year estimates.
IndicatorValueSource
Annual snowfall44.1 in.NOAA NCEI
January mean temperature28.8°FNOAA NCEI
Annual precipitation39.6 in.NOAA NCEI
Housing units built before 198073.1%U.S. Census Bureau
Single-family detached share68.0%U.S. Census Bureau
Owner-occupied share70.7%U.S. Census Bureau

Snowfall normals are a 30-year average for one station. Actual accumulation on a roof depends on pitch, drifting and how long it sits before a melt.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I replace a slate roof with asphalt shingles?

Usually not without a specializt's assessment. A leak in a slate roof is often a flashing or fastener problem rather than a failed covering, and replacement shortens the roof's life dramatically. Ask someone who actually works on slate.

How do I stop ice dams?

Keep the roof deck cold: seal air leaks at the ceiling plane, insulate to current standards, and make sure soffit intake and ridge exhaust are clear. Heat cable and raking manage symptoms; the membrane under the covering is the backstop.

Can I put a second layer of shingles on?

It may be permitted depending on how many layers exist, but it hides the deck and adds weight. Ask for the current layer count in writing and for the tear-off price, including staging and disposal on a steep lot.

Why does my attic grow frost in winter?

Warm moist air is reaching a cold surface, usually from leaks at the ceiling plane or a bath fan discharging into the attic. Air sealing and ventilation fix it; more insulation alone often does not.

Is access a real cost on a hillside lot?

Yes. Staging, scaffolding and disposal on a steep property are practical costs that vary widely, and they belong in the comparison between bids rather than appearing later as extras.

How long does a roof last here?

It depends on the covering, the ventilation and the exposure. A maintained slate roof can last generations, while an under-ventilated asphalt roof on a hot south slope can fail well before its rating.

Sources and review date

Reviewed on 2026-11-18.

Other Home Services in Pittsburgh